"You have been in Afghanistan, I perceive."This is a quote from the first Sherlock Holmes story, "A Study in Scarlet". Holmes makes this observation when he first meets Watson. Watson had served in Afghanistan during the Second Afghan war that took place between 1878 - 1880. Holmes was able to deduce this by his appearance and knowing that Watson was a doctor.
Recently, I saw the pilot episode of "Sherlock", the BBC series featuring Holmes in a modern setting. When John Watson meets Holmes for the first time, this exchange happens:
Sherlock: Afghanistan or Iraq?
John: Sorry?
Sherlock: Which one was it? In Afghanistan or Iraq?
John: Afghanistan. Sorry, how did you...?
In a nod to the original story, Holmes correctly deduces that Watson is a former military doctor who was wounded in action in Afghanistan. In this case, he asks which country it was, since he can't figure that out from his appearance alone.
The amazing thing about this to me is that it's 130 years later, and British soldiers are still fighting in Afghanistan. You know, if the West doesn't have control of the country by now, maybe it's time to give it a rest.
